The New York Knicks thought they had a lock on Tyler Nickel. The No. 47 pick looked ready for a two-way deal or a spot in the rotation. Now that plan is in big trouble. CBS Sports’ Isaac Trotter reported that Nickel is “expected to explore” returning to college instead of starting his pro career in 2026-27. That single line changes everything for the roster construction this summer.
A sudden shift in plans
The Knicks just moved out of the first round to save cap space. They wanted cheap, young talent like Nickel and Jack Kayil to fill the bench. But the legal landscape changed fast. A recent ruling allows players to compete for five college seasons. Nickel already entered the NCAA transfer portal back in April. He could make more money through name, image, and likeness deals at school than on a standard NBA contract. It makes perfect sense for him to stay home.
According to reports, Nickel is one of five second-round picks who have not signed yet. He joins players like Richie Saunders and Dillon Mitchell in this group. While Braden Smith, the No. 38 pick, is done with school, Nickel is not. His representatives told reporters that he wants to look at his options. The Knicks cannot force him to sign if the math favors college.
Why this might actually help New York
Many fans will panic about losing a promising rookie. But the Knicks owner James Dolan has strict rules about the second apron. The team cannot just throw money at players to fill holes. If Nickel stays in college, the Knicks save a roster spot and a chunk of cash. They can use that money elsewhere. They can look for a veteran shooter or a backup center who is ready to play now.
Per Posting and Toasting, the team already has uncertainty with Jack Kayil, who likely heads to Germany. Losing Nickel too feels like a blow. But it frees the front office from a bad fit. A two-way contract is not a guaranteed path to success. Sometimes a player needs more time to grow. If Nickel comes back as a fifth-year senior, he might be a much better player for the Knicks later. The team does not need to rush him.
The Knicks shaped their 2026-27 roster around the idea of cheap rookies. Now that idea is gone. The team must pivot fast. They have to find other ways to fill the bench without breaking the cap rules. The front office knows this. They have been watching the portal since April. If Nickel leaves, they just have to find the next guy. The season starts soon. The Knicks need to be ready.
