Giants’ Zvada Struggles Spark Debate Over Ben Sauls Options

More Stories

Giants Add Veteran Safety Tavierre Thomas To Active Roster

The New York Giants signed veteran defensive back Tavierre Thomas from the Vikings practice squad. See the stats and what this move means for the team.

A.J. Minter Draws Interest From Five Teams Including Royals

The Kansas City Royals join four other clubs chasing 33-year-old lefty A.J. Minter after he posted career highs in WHIP and K/BB ratio for the Mets.

Pete Alonso Crushes Mets Reality With 43 Home Runs For Orioles

Pete Alonso hit 43 homers and drove in 113 runs for Baltimore in 2026. RotoBaller breaks down the stats that prove he is still an elite power threat.

Mets Pitch To Tarik Skubal As Clock Ticks Toward Lockout

The Mets made a major in-person pitch to Tarik Skubal on Monday. New York Post reports the team is a top contender with time running out before the lockout.

Giants’ Zvada Struggles Spark Debate Over Ben Sauls Options

Dominic Zvada faces heat after recent misses. Giants fans wonder if Ben Sauls is the fix, but roster rules and leg strength issues complicate the choice.

Rookie kicker Dominic Zvada is drawing sharp criticism from a loud group of New York Giants fans who want him off the roster. The pressure comes after a rough stretch where the young kicker missed six of his last 14 field-goal attempts. While the start of the season looked perfect with nine straight makes, the last four games have shown clear cracks in his game. Per Big Blue View, a vocal part of the fan base believes the team should have already booted Zvada to the curb.

Head coach John Harbaugh pushed back against the idea of making a quick change during the week. “You can’t, as soon as a guy doesn’t make a play, start firing people left and right,” he said. He noted that finding a new player who is definitely better is much harder than just saying someone has to go.

The Case for Keeping Zvada

Blowing the whistle on Zvada right now might not fix the real problem. Per Big Blue View, the main issue is a much-discussed problem from the right hash mark that has cost the team points. Even with the misses, Zvada has proven he can hit the big shots that other kickers might dread.

Why Ben Sauls Is Not the Answer

Many fans point to left-footed Ben Sauls as the savior who could fix the kicking woes. Sauls was an elixir for the Giants at the end of the 2025 season, making all 15 of his kicks over a three-game span. His record included eight field goals and seven extra points, with a longest kick of 45 yards. However, the Giants cannot just call him up if he is not on the team. Big Blue View reports that Ben Sauls is not on a 53-man roster or practice squad at this time.

There is also a question of whether Sauls can handle the long kicks Zvada attempts. While Sauls was great in the spring and summer, he had his own technique issues before the season started. During summer practice, he was not nearly as consistent as Zvada, having been terrible in the spring by consistently pushing kicks to the left. When the two kickers competed for the spot, deciding which of them should win the job was easily done.

The Harbaugh Reality Check

John Harbaugh knows that swapping players is easy in theory but hard in practice. The Giants do not have a ready-made replacement sitting on the bench who can hit 50-yarders with confidence.

The Giants will face the Jacksonville Jaguars next on Sunday, Nov. 22, at 4:25 p.m. ET at MetLife Stadium.

Add Gameday New York City as a preferred source on Google

Dallin Ballard
Dallin Ballard
Dallin Ballard is a contributor to the GameDay Network.

Subscribe

- Never miss a story with notifications

Latest stories